Total Viewers

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Why Pakistan has been broken down in 1971?

____________________________________________________________________________
Related Topics:
______________________________________________________________________

There are many reasons behind it like below:

1)    Disintegrations in Culture, Politics and Economies
2)    Political and Economic Exploitation
3)    Political and military ambition of the then West Pakistanis
4)    Lack of trust
5)    Mentality of the west Pakistanis

Map of Pakistan (1947-1971)
Map collected from Wikipedia.org

In 1947, the British India had been divided into two countries based on two nations’ theory. One part became “India”, the secular one and other part emerged as “Pakistan”, based on the religion of  Islam. The distance of the two wings (provinces) of Pakistan was huge, more than 1,500 km and India being lain down between those two wings. Geographically unshaped and discontented, Pakistan emerged as a sovereign country in the region based on the sentiment of Islam. The majority people of Pakistan were Muslims (85.9% in 1951)1 in belief and other portion mainly of Hindus.


Muslims were afraid to be merged into the overwhelmingly majority of Hindus in India. The Hindus were the most progressive in all spheres of the state, they were mostly highly educated, cultural and advanced in economic conditions than those of Muslims. Hence, they (under the leadership of Muslim League) demanded separate sovereign country for the Muslim majority portion and the result of that was Pakistan.
Mohammad Ali Zinnah 
The founder of Pakistan

But from the very beginning, the West Pakistani establishment tried to exploit Bengalis in every sector of the state. They adopted the policy to dominate them in politics as well as in economic sector too. So, the dream of the Bengali nation in the eastern part of Pakistan, were faded out rapidly. Firstly, they got shocked in the name of state language, Mohammad Ali Jinnah declared in Dhaka in 1948 that Urdu would be the only state language for Pakistan, though the majority were the Bengali (56.40% in 1951)2 and their language, culture and literature were too strong and rich in the region. On 21 February 1952, Pakistan police shot down some agitators in Dhaka while they were demanding ‘Bangla’ as the state language along with Urdu. This incidence turned Bengali to the Bengali nationalism. Thus the political disintegration had been started in Pakistan.

Sheikh Mujibur Rahman
The founder of Bangladesh

The economic policy was the total violation of parity in the provinces. The West Pakistani establishment adopted the policy to exploit the Bengali in distribution of budget, foreign aid, grants, loans and state revenue in the development sectors and they grabbed major portion of the financial flow for the west. Their adopted policy was so much tricky and exploiting type in character that the Bengali had started to demand their equality in the form of autonomy by expressing the Six Points demand under the leadership of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. The following 3 tables (Table-1 - 3) have been revealed the actual scenarios of the economic exploitation by the West Pakistani establishment.

Table-1: Distribution of central government's revenue expenditure,
1947-1948 to 1960-1961 (Note: 1 crore =10 million).
Sector


East Pakistan
West Pakistan
Unallocable
Rs. In
Crore
%of
Total
Rs. In
Crore
%of
Total
Rs. In
Crore
%of
Total
Revenue expenditure including working expenses of commercial departments
269.00
12%
995.00
45%
952.00
43%
Revenue expenditure excluding working expenses of commercial departments
  86.00
5%
616.00
34%
1,138.00
61%

Source: "Pakistan: failure in national integration" by Rounaq Jahan, p. 34. (Adapted from East Pakistan, Planning   Department, Economic Disparities Between East and West Pakistan (1963), p. 17).

The most of the un-allocable portion of the Government revenue had been used in the west wing and for the Army of Pakistan.

Table-2: Central government development outlay, 1947-48 to 1960-1961
Sector



East Pakistan
West Pakistan
Total
(Rs. in
 Crore)
Per
Capita
(Rs.)
Total
(Rs. in
 Crore)
Per
Capita
(Rs.)
Investment
172.00
38.00
430.00
117.00
Loans
184.00
40.00
224.00
61.00
Grants-in-aid
76.00
15.00
101.00
28.00
Source: "Pakistan: failure in national integration" by Rounaq Jahan, p. 34 (Adapted from East Pakistan, Planning Department, Economic Disparities Between East and West Pakistan (1963). P.18.

Table-3:  Foreign aid and loans 1947-48 to June 30, 1960
Sector


East Pakistan
West Pakistan
Center
Total
Rs. In
Crore
% of
Total
Rs. In
Crore
% of
Total
Rs. In
Crore
% of
Total
Rs. In
Crore
Foreign Development aid
  93.89
17%
335.22
62%
113.03
21%
542.14
U.S. commodity aid
129.00
30%
262.00
64%
18.00
6%
409.00
Source: "Pakistan: failure in national integration" by Rounaq Jahan, p. 35 (Adapted from East Pakistan, Planning Department, Economic Disparities Between East and West Pakistan (1963), p. 21)


The 'center portion' of the above table (table-3) had been spent mainly for the west wing of Pakistan.


In the political sector, Bengalis were neglected by the West Pakistani establishment. Though the Bengalis were the majority population in Pakistan, political power remained firmly in the hands of West Pakistanis. But according to the straightforward system of representation based on population, the political power would have been concentrated in East Pakistan. After the assassination of Pakistan’s first Prime Minister, Liaquat Ali Khan in 1951, Pakistan army was getting stronger and stronger to grab the power.

Another alarming thing had been noticed to the East Pakistanis that whenever one of them, such as Khawja  Nazimuddin, Mohammad Ali Bogra, or Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy was elected as Prime Minister of Pakistan, he were swiftly deposed by the largely West Pakistani establishment. The military dictatorships of Ayub Khan and Yahya Khan, both West Pakistanis, only widen the fear feelings of the East Pakistanis.

Gen. Ayub Khan
The introducer
of so-called "Basic Democracy"
in Pakistan

The basic democracy of Ayub Khan (27 October 1958 – 25 March 1969) was nothing but a trick to establish the military regime (which was dominated by the West Pakistanis) on strong feet in Pakistan and naturally, East Pakistanis could not accept that doctrine in heart and soul. Rather they saw it as an effort to produce some agents or touts in the society to strengthen the hands of the military regimes in Pakistan. In the Liberation War of Bangladesh, 1971 the leaders of Muslim League and Jamat-e-Islam proved themselves as the die-hard supporters of Pakistan Army and their establishment. They directly took part in the mass killings of the civilians, mass destruction of the infra-structures of East Pakistan (Bangladesh), plundering, raping on behalf of the Pakistan's brutal army.


Actually Ayub Khan, like other West Pakistani establishment, did not believe in democracy and they knew that, if democracy prevailed in Pakistan, the political power would be in the hand of East Pakistanis. In that context, the Awami League produced their most popular “Six Points” demand in front of the people to establish a separate economy and administration (almost full autonomy) for the East Pakistan.

In that period, the military regime banded the songs of Rabindranath Tagor, the most respected poet and literate of Bengali nation, in the state-owned media (Radio and TV), which actually made the gap widen between East Pakistanis and West Pakistanis.

The representation of East Pakistanis in the military sector in Pakistan was also very poor. The West Pakistanis controlled the power of recruitment in the army and they did not want to create better positions for the East Pakistanis. The table-4 & 5 showed the poor representation figure of the East Pakistani in Pakistan military.

Table-4: East Pakistani representation in the military establishment, 1963 (percentage of total)

Sector
Commissioned
Officers
Junior
Commissioned
Officers
Warrant Officers
Other Ranks
Army
5%
7.40%
-
7.4%
Air Force
17%
-
13.20%
28.0%

Branch Officers
Chief Petty Officers
Petty Officers
Leading Seamen and below
Navy
5%
10.4%
17.3%
28.8%
Source: Pakistan, National Assembly, Debates, March 8, 1963. PP. 30-31 (from the book “Pakistan: failure of national integration” by Rounaq Jahan, University Press Limited, pp. 62).

Table-5: Military elite in Pakistan, July 1955 (no. of officers).

Service
East Pakistan
West Pakistan
Army
14
894
Navy
7
593
Air Force
60
640
Source: Dawn (Karachi). Adapted from the book of Rounaq Jahan, “Pakistan: failure of national integration” University Press Limited, pp. 25).


In the administrative sector, the representation of East Pakistan was poor too. The below table (table-6) shows the actual figures of the representation in the Administrative sector of East Pakistan.

Table-6: East-West representation in the higher ranks of the Central Secretary, 1955.
Rank
East Pakistan
West Pakistan
East
% of Total
Secretary
--
19
--
Joint Secretary
3
38
7.3%
Deputy Secretary
10
123
7.5%
Undersecretary
38
510
7.0%
Source: "Pakistan: failure in national integration" by Rounaq Jahan, p. 26 (Adapted from:
‘Pakistan, Constituent Assembly, Debates’. Vol.I, January 17, 1956. P. 1844)


The exploiters (West Pakistanis) never believed the East Pakistanis at all and they acted as colonialist and by hook or by crook, they tried to keep East Pakistan just as their colony.


The situation further deteriorated after the general election of 1970. In that election, Awami League won the fresh majority and became eligible to form the Government in Pakistan. But the Pakistani military authority and their political leaders, like Zulfikar Ali Bhutto denied to allow them to form the government.

National Council Election, 1970


The election was held on 7 December 1970. The total voters were 29,479,386 and the casting votes were 17,005,163 (57.68%), the valid casting votes were 16,454,278.

The summary of the National Council Election, 1970  [3]
Sl.
No.
Political Party
Total
candidates
Seats
captured
Percentage
of total
casting
vote
1
Awami League
162
160
74.9%
2
PDP
79
1
2.9%
3
Niajm-e-Islami
49
0
0%
4
Jamaat-e-Islami
70
0
6%
5
Pakistan Muslim League (Convention)
93
0
2.8%
6
Pakistan Muslim League (Kou)
50
0
1.6%
7
Pakistan Muslim League (Kayum)
65
0
1%
8
National Awami Party (Wali)
39
0
1.8%
9
Independent (politician)
114
1
3.4%

Provincial Council Election, 1970


The election was held on 17 December 1970. The percentage of casting votes was (57.69%), and the number of reserved women seat was 10.

The summary of the Provincial Council Election, 1970  [4]
Sl.
No.
Political Party
Total
Candidates
Seats
Captured
Percentage
Symbol
1
Awami League
300
288
89%
Boat
2
PDP
-
2
1%
3
Niajm-e-Islami
-
1
-
4
Jamaat-e-Islami
-
1
3%
5
Pakistan Muslim League (Convention)
-
0
1%
6
Pakistan Muslim League (Kou)
-
0
0.05%
7
Pakistan Muslim League (Kayum)
-
0
0.05%
8
National Awami Party (Wali)
-
1
0.9%
9
Independent (politician)
-
7
5%


In these elections, Sheikh Mujib emerged as an undisputed leader of the East Pakistanis with 268 of the 279 seats in the East Pakistan Provincial Assembly going to the Awami League.

Paki-Demon: Gen. Yahya Khan

At this stage, the situation reached the climax and in the face of their demand to form the government, Yahya Khan declared the state of emergency and attacked the East Pakistanis in Dhaka on 25 th March, 1971 under the code name "Operation Search Light" to eliminate AL and its supporters and brutally killed around 7,000 people in a single night and around 30,000 people in Dhaka within a week. Their systematic slaughtering and ethnic cleansing had been carried out till 16 December, 1971.


Within 9 months' time (from March 25 to December 16, 1971), those hyenas slaughtered around 3.0 million people and they raped around 200,000-400,000 women in the name to protect “Islam” in Pakistan!

After the brutal attack in East Pakistan, to support this dirty war of West Pakistanis, Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto told in a press meeting on 26 March, 1971, "God has saved Pakistan!" (Genocidebangladesh.org).

They torched the villages after villages, destroyed roads, railways, buildings and bridges unanimously. Around 10.0 million people had to take refuge in the neighboring India.

Genocide-1971: Victims of
Paki-hyenas & their dirty war

This incident pined the last pin on the coffin of the joint Pakistan and ignited in the struggle of the East Pakistanis to establish their legal demand and turned it to the independence of East Pakistan as "Bangladesh". But Bangladesh met up the prices of the independence by the huge death of its people in the hand of those hyenas of West Pakistani army and their collaborators (Razakar/Al-Bador/Al-Shams, etc. - mainly from Jamat-e-Islam and Muslim League) of East Pakistan. 

Golam Azam 

Head of Collaborators of Pakistan, 1971

Motiur Rahman Nizamee
Head of Al-Bador, Pakistan, 1971

Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujahid
Head of Al-Bador, East Pakistan, 1971

Not only that the Bengali nation lost more than 1,000 of their most prominent and literate persons, intellectuals, professionals and scientists in the hands of their collaborators (Al-Bador and Al-Shams - from the 'Islamic Chhatro Sangha' / 'Islamic Students Organization', the students' wings of Jamat-e-Islam, Pakistan) under the direct supervision of General Rao Farman Ali (a notorious butcher of West Pakistan) just 3-2 days prior to their surrender in Bangladesh.

Rayer Bazar Martyrdom: Dead bodies of martyrs

The butchers did it systematically to make Bangladesh intellectual-less to stop the future progress of Bangladesh, who could guide newly born Bangladesh in the forthcoming time. The killing squads of Al-Bador and Al-Shams picked up the progressive minded intellectuals and professionals from their houses and killed them brutally and unmercifully mostly in several places in the Dhaka City, like at Rayer Bazar, Mirpur, Pallabi, etc.

Now Bangladesh is liberated one and a sovereign country   in the World, but the Bengali of East Bengal (Bangladesh) paid the prices for their liberation with huge deaths and pains in the hands of those hyenas of Pakistan Army and their collaborators.
______________________________________________________________________
1 Population census of Pakistan, 1961, Vol.I, pt. i, statement 2.18, Table-5. Adapted from the book of RounaqJahan, ‘Pakistan: failure in national integration’. Table II.7, Page: 23.

2 Population census of Pakistan, 1961, Vol.I, pt. iv, statement 5.3.Adapted from the book of RounaqJahan, ‘Pakistan: failure in national integration’. Page: 12.

No comments:

Post a Comment